I read these books a few days ago so my
impressions are a bit stale, but I have a lot to say about them, or at least I
did.
My classification of the books as
plot-based did not need to change at all through the series. The characters
have enough quirks to be distinctive, but they're not really deep. I like at
least a little bit of romance, and given that the main character is male and
his companion is female, it only makes sense for this to come up. But the
closest it comes to this is a ship-tease, where for half a paragraph or so the
woman notices how close the man is or something like that and her cheeks warm
up. Seriously, there is no examination of feelings whatsoever. The man is even
worse--from his point of view, the only hint of him having any romantic
inclinations whatsoever are when he sees women under-dressed and gets
embarrassed. It's unrealistic in my opinion, but it's hardly the only thing. But
it is kind of nice that such a fantasy series exists when so many modern
fantasy series are obsessed with sex and even sexual deviancy.
The writing is quite good. It gives enough
details that to avoid both the cold, empty environments of that fanfiction
writer ShayneT and the plodding pace of most high fantasy novels. Although, to
be honest, I do skim the battle sections because they tend to have more detail
than I like.
If I could sum up these books in a
sentence, I would call them “An RPG/fighting game converted as well as possible
into a book series”. Furthermore, I think they would make a great video game if
anyone decided to do that adaptation. There is very little that happens in the
book which isn’t fighting, training, or planning to fight or train, or being
subjected to the will of someone thereby leading to fighting. I found myself
constantly amazed at the author’s continuing escalation of conflict. The main
character starts at the bottom of the power totem pole, but by the end of the
sixth book he is (apparently) practically a god compared to the people who pushed
him around growing up. Throughout the series he is constantly making (stronger
and stronger) bitter enemies who are defeated sooner or later. It gets a little
old.
In conclusion, this is an exciting series
that worked well as a time killer, but I don’t expect to remember any details
in a year. Which might be nice—maybe I’ll be able to enjoy it a second time
just because it was so unmemorable.
No comments:
Post a Comment